• Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Research
  • Teaching
  • Blog
  • Placement data

Soaked feet, bone-dry cuffs

Mind & psychology. A little bit of epistemology. Plenty of other stuff. Lots of swearing. Some jokes, mostly self-deprecating. Everything's coming up Milhouse.

Kind of a rhetorical question about situationism

8/8/2019

 
The basic idea of situationism, in a nutshell, is that: 
​1. virtues motivate behavior
2. behavior is controlled by external factors (why? because social psychology)
3. virtues are internal
4. so, (by 2 & 3) virtues don't motivate behavior

Granted, a really rough characterization, but not too far off the mark. But just about any psych study will gesture in some way towards effect sizes. The environment is part of the cause for some behavior, but clearly not the whole story -- otherwise, the effect sizes for these studies would be ginormous. And they just aren't. But the studies are supposed to keep the environment the same, so variance in response is unlikely due to other environmental factors (or at least not solely to other environmental factors.) Is there some a priori argument why causes of variance can't be internal factors? It seems if the virtue theorist can get their foot in the door this way, it's a problem for most strains of situationism.

Plus, you know, individual variability in responses is a thing in psych. I guess the point of situationism isn't to eliminate internal factors but rather to show that they can't do the work needed to count as a character trait that might be developed into a virtue?

    Author

    I do mind and epistemology and have an irrational interest in data analysis and agent-based modeling. 

    Archives

    December 2021
    October 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    November 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019

    Categories

    All
    But They're Not So Big
    Data
    Empty Promises
    Epistemology
    Introductions
    Music
    Philoso Twitter
    Philoso-twitter
    Professional Navel Gazing
    Professional Navel-gazing
    Psychology
    Rhetorical?

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.